2 reviews for Tile Deal (Magic Tile Puzzle) by Martin Duffy, Winston Freer
If you want to submit a product review click here.
If you want to submit a product review click here.
By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information
The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.
Andy Martin –
Wow! Winston Freer was a Genius! What an incredible miracle this effect is! Very different in method from anything similar that I have seen. This is based on a principle developed by Paul Curry called the Curry Paradaox c. 1953. However Freer adds an ingenious allowance for the area lost by redistribution which allows you to show the area to be EXACTLY THE SAME, before and after the removal of three tiles.
This is a really great version of the Tile Deal or Magic Tile Puzzle by Winston Freer built by Martin Duffy of the UK. It is very nicely made and finished. It is very similar in size and dimensions to the John Rogers version, but this is all wood instead of Corian tiles. It could even be an early version of John Rogers version.
To be honest although the definitive collector’s version is probably the John Rogers version, if you want to perform this effect, then this all wooden version is easier to perform. It is about 10oz lighter and the tiles are easier to get out by hand instead of having to tip them out. If you are a casual performer it won’t matter, but if you were doing this a lot I think the Corian would be harder to use. Also I think the Corian might in fact be more brittle because in the instructions is says perform on a soft mat to avoid chipping the tiles.)
(Notice: the three final photos show a comparison with the John Rogers version, but of course you only get this wooden one.)
Mark Paul –
Love this version of The Winston Freer puzzle. This is fantastic value for money. Really nicely made. I added a couple of my own touches. Very happy with this. It’s definitely a worker and not a version to sit on a shelf in your collection. I was tempted with higher end versions but this version from Martin is a lot more durable. Also check out Martins Chocolate version. Another fantastic version of this AWESOME puzzle. The Winston Freer Puzzle.
10/10 Martin